I was going with the list until I saw who they gave #1 to. No way, man. She's the worst of all the winners.
I agree with Elliott being totally underrated. He's my favorite contestant from all the seasons.
The 10 Greatest 'American Idol' Contestants Of All Time
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 PoetryNjcEyes |
|||
|
Posts: 9307 (05/22/2009 5:35 PM) |
|
||
|
PoetryNjcEyes |
|||
|
Posts: 9308 (05/22/2009 5:41 PM) |
AlwaysSomeoneElse wrote: I totally agree. She was awful on the show...and her attitude was ridiculous. |
||
 susanlynn7 |
|||
|
Posts: 18973 (05/22/2009 6:02 PM) |
XxBlondeshavemorefunxX wrote: I agree. Can't believe 'ole catscratch is #1. |
||
|
Pebbles theBabygal |
|||
|
Posts: 1112 (05/22/2009 7:55 PM) |
1. Kelly 2. Carrie 3. Daughtry 4. Cookie 5. Lambert 6. Who the fuck cares about the rest.
|
||
|
BlondeyGirl |
|||
|
Posts: 2264 (05/22/2009 8:29 PM) |
Fantasia is #1? Really??
|
||
|
hinatha |
|||
|
Posts: 2581 (05/22/2009 8:36 PM) |
fantasia sucks. what are they smoking?
|
||
|
June 2010 |
|||
|
Posts: 684 (05/22/2009 11:52 PM) |
The list should be without Fantasia and ANYONE from the last two seasons.
|
||
|
Faith Hope and Trick |
|||
|
Posts: 2473 (05/23/2009 1:23 AM) |
that list is fucking wrong when it comes to Clay and Fantasia. WTF. And HOW is Jordin not on there??
|
||
|
saturn02 |
|||
|
Posts: 797 (05/23/2009 4:35 AM) |
I personally don't get Fantasia's appeal. I hate the way she interprets songs (except for Summertime which was ace), but she is an undeniably
interesting, if not great performer, so I think she should be on the list, just not number one. Carrie Underwood's appeal, on the other hand, I understand
less than Fantasia's. At least Fannie has a unique voice and memorable performances, but Carrie sounds like every girl that sang in my high school choir.
There's nothing distinct, original or even special about her voice. IMO, she won and has success because she has half-way decent chops and is a pretty
girl. But, my is she BORING. On the other hand, I'm glad LaToya and Yamin made the list. Woot!
|
||
|
soursberries |
|||
|
Posts: 1513 (05/23/2009 6:23 AM) |
Fantasia sucks I don't get why she's number 1
|
||
|
yankeefanNcali |
|||
|
Posts: 3151 (05/23/2009 8:26 AM) |
JustBrit2007 wrote: |
||
|
cheddarcheese2 |
|||
|
Posts: 3999 (05/23/2009 11:22 AM) |
Yay for Elliott
 he should be higher up
|
||
|
cinnabon83 |
|||
|
Posts: 13612 (05/23/2009 11:27 AM) |
saturn02 wrote: I COULD NOT AGREE MORE. Seriously. |
||
